|
Can Stainless Steel Swords be Used as
Weapons?
Can stainless steel swords be used as weapons? Yes and no. Even though
many replica swords - especially replica katanas - have a sharp
edge and can be used to cut, this does not make such a sword a
reliable weapon, as any sharpened length of metal can do the
same!
There are serveral issues one must take into account when considering a
stainless steel replica sword as a personal weapon:
(Many thanks to Motoyasu for providing excellent technical information on
Japanese swords!)
Safety
A stainless blade is much weaker than a comparable blade of plain carbon
steel would be. Also, the materials of replica swords tend to be
substandard because they were made at low cost, e.g. plastic or scrap
softwood hilts, badly fitted, very short partial tangs, loose fittings,
etc.. Thus, all of these factors can represent a source of possible
failure and a safety hazard to you or anyone around you. It may not happen
today or even for years, but if you ask around the dojos (martial arts
practice centers), you'll find that breakage of these swords has occured
with frightening regularity - some were hilt failures, others were blade
failures, none (so far, fortunately) have been fatal. But do you want to
take that chance?
Cutting Ability
Replica swords were meant for display and not for actual use, so they have
many deficiencies in terms of geometry, curvature, weight, balance. This
is most certainly the case with replica Japanese swords!
With replica Japanese swords, the "razor sharp edge" these swords most
often come with (especially Taiwanese made swords) actually contribute a
great deal to cutting resistance if compared with a real Japanese sword.
These replic katanas are sharpened by grinding a bevel about 1/16"
or so wide on the edge of the blade. Not only can this never be as sharp
as a sword without the bevel, but even this minute little ridge
contributes a great deal to cutting resistance.
At a more technical level, replica blades typically have flat sides.
Sharpened in the way they are, replica swords may have a larger edge angle
than real Japanese swords, but the shape of the blade means increased
cutting resistance as the object being cut will touch the flat all the way
through the cut, while with a real Japanese sword - where the sides are
slightly convex - the object being cut would only contact a single point
on the curved surface.
The convex edge is also tougher than a flat-sided edge and resists
chipping better! The narrower trailing edge in a real sword results in no
contact with the object. The diamond cross section also increases rigidity
of the blade, making it less likely to bend.
Curvature
Many replica Japanese swords do not have the proper amount of curvature.
In some cases, the curvature occurs on the wrong place on the blade. Many
wall-hanger swords, unfortunately , have a short, straight hilt which does
not follow the curvature of the blade. All of these reasons can result in
a blade being more likely to chop than cut. By design, a Japanese
katana's true strength comes from its ability to cut, not as a
chopping weapon. Thus, improper use such as chopping can result in
bending or breaking a sword! Even if you do manage to perform a cut with
a replica sword, because of the wrong sized hilt, you usually cannot
generate sufficient power in the cut!
Weight & Balance
There are also issues with weight and balance. Most replicas are too
heavy or too light, and their balance is either way too blade heavy or too
far down towards the hilt, with obvious consequences for cutting and other
use of the sword.
Durability
Replicas are generally made of substandard materials which means there
were compromises in the physical quality of the sword. Because of this,
replica blades usually end up not being able to hold an edge under use.
If you sharpen it and leave it, the edge will be fine, but if you cut with
it, after a few cuts, you will find that it has dulled already! Compare
this to a real katana where you'll probably never have to
resharpen it in your lifetime unless you chip it. The cheap fittings on
replica swords will typically deteriorate and fall apart very quickly
because they are just for appearance and not for use.
Conclusion
So in summary, while any sharp blade certainly can be used to cut with,
the durability of such swords is an issue: the edge will not stand up to
any abuse, the fittings and furniture may fall apart on you. Also, because
the blade is intended for display, its shape, geometry and balance are not
optimized for actual use. While this particular deficiency can to an
extent be compensated for by good technique, the paramount concern should
be safety- again, replica swords are meant for display, not for real use,
so they typically use substandard materials that may break and cause
injury. Replica swords should be used only for display purposes, any kind
of use, even stage fighting, should be done using swords made for the
purpose.
|